You Can’t Always Get What You Want

red rose

One would assume that the week that the Prime Minister resigns is, on balance, quite a good week for the opposition. Sadly the Labour Party appear to have decided to compete with the Conservatives to win the: “Which party can self-destruct the fastest” competition and for once Labour are winning hands-down.

Last summer I voted for Jeremy Corbyn to be the leader of the Labour Party. There were a number of factors that influenced my decision. The worst being I was still reeling from the result of the General Election which I knew would lead to the country becoming more unequal. Broadly speaking, I would describe myself, like Corbyn, as a democratic socialist, and just like the Brexiteers say of the referendum, last Summer was the first time I saw an option that closely reflected my political views on a ballot paper. Most significantly, I didn’t see a strong enough alternative being put forward. I would have been more than happy to vote for the candidate I saw winning a general election over the person that shared my own personal views but I wasn’t convinced that any of them could.  I’ve got a lot of time for Yvettte Cooper, I think she’s great but for a significant percentage of the country she (unfairly) represents the Blair years. Andy Burnham seemed unable to decide what he stood for although in hindsight would have perhaps risen to the task and  Liz Kendall had plenty of sensible things to say but an unfortunate patronising way of saying them.  I don’t speak to 6-year-olds the way she addressed those hustings audiences.  So Corbyn it was.  Had there been a Stella Creasy, or Dan Jarvis on the ballot paper then things may have been different; it was a self-indulgent way to vote but it felt like the right thing to do at the time. Above all I’m an optimist (yes, really) and genuinely believed if we could just get people to hear what was on offer they couldn’t not agree with it. I was wrong.

I live in Haringey which is as close as a teacher can get to living in Corbyn’s Islington constituency whilst still affording to eat. I am a member of the Labour party, I attend ward meetings and represent my ward at General Committee meetings. It’s clear that amongst the members in those meetings the support for Corbyn is still strong. I wish I could share their confidence. It is all too easy to sit in a room and shake our heads at the state of country and curse those terrible Tories but unless we are able to gain the power needed to change things we may as well  be the WI tutting about the way of the world.

It’s no secret that the decision the country made in the referendum shocked me – it was a real wake-up call and we all need to learn what we can from it. I am now less certain about things I was previously confident about. The only thing one can be sure of is that in the next 6 – 12 months it is likely that there will be a General Election and I don’t think Jeremy Corbyn can win in.

In the referendum the country voted with Nigel Farage: the most right-wing politician with such a high level of exposure since Enoch Powell, if not Oswald Mosley . They are not exactly crying out for socialism. We need to address the country on their terms not ours and we need to accept them as they are not as what we hope they are deep down “if we can just convince them.” I know that it is normal for the opposition to pull further left when facing a right-wing government but that would be a mistake. We need to find the midpoint position ourselves between our members and the PLP and we need to do it soon. For the poorest people in our country, life is getting harder at an exponential rate. Wanting to win an election so we can actually start improving life for the people we claim to represent does not make me a Blairite, despite the insistence of Corbyn’s supporters on describing anyone who opposes him in this way.

I’m not saying we should abandon our values altogether but they need to be packaged correctly. The public say they hate spin and soundbite politicians but just over a week ago, Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage convinced over 17 million people to vote to leave the EU by repeating three little words: “Take Back Control”. Similarly last year, Obsorne’s “long-term economic plan” helped seal the Conservative majority. The public feel comforted by a well-dressed politician with a reassuring soundbite.“I know appearance is superficial, but people judge people by their appearances and when you see politicians in their smart suits, and then Jeremy Corbyn is there, he looks like he has just come off his allotment, and people aren’t drawn to him.” said one ex. Labour voter in response to the question “Do you like Jeremy Corbyn?

Nationalism is back in a big way and it comes hand in hand with its close friend Royalism. The country wants to see their Prime Minister singing the National Anthem. Personally I think the Royal Family are a waste of tax-payers’ money and it’s a shame they weren’t one of the victims of austerity cuts instead of funding for hospitals and schools. However I know that my view is not the view of the majority – a YouGov poll last September found that 71% of adults believe that the monarchy should remain. I also know that just shouting louder and louder that the monarchy are a waste of money will not change people’s minds.

The country also do not want to talk about reopening coal mines, scrapping trident or quantitative easing. Once again my opinion on some of these issues is at odds with the majority and for most people those ideas are scary – they appear risky and radical. We lost the election last year because Rupert Murdoch and Lynton Crosby managed to convince voters that the Labour Party could not be trusted with the economy. One year on and our economy is increasing unstable as a result of the referendum result: the Conservative Party line that Labour can’t be trusted with our economy has been shot to pieces. Now is the time for a strong leader offering a clear vision that the public can relate to. Now is NOT the time for the Shadow Chancellor to be quoting from Mao’s Little Red Book or to talk about printing more money. People want shorter hospital waiting lists, school places for their children and a better quality of life but more than anything they want to feel secure. We have to discuss the issues the general public want addressed and not just keep banging on about Trident. That is another argument for another time.

Corbyn is a good man and, by all accounts, an excellent local MP. I wanted him to be the leader of the Labour Party. But to quote Sir Jagger, “You can’t always get what you want but if you try sometimes, you just might find, you get what you need.”

7 thoughts on “You Can’t Always Get What You Want

  1. While I wouldn’t agree with some of your politics your analysis is spot on. In our system you need a coherent and effective opposition to ensure the government is made to justify itself and not take advantage of the other side’s weaknesses to deflect criticism. It was much the same when Blair was faced by Howard and IDS or Thatcher by Foot. Enjoying your musings!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. My head agrees but my heart does not! My heart yearns for a different kind of politics. I think Jetemy Corbyn represents that kind but, a bit like Obama, the system just defeats him. The elite bunch will always win. As for the voters, I am afraid I blame our poor education system. It suits the elite well to keep the electorate ignorant and the workers in their place. Thatcher knew this only too well. The poor are poor but happy to stay poor! Maybe we see signs of that breaking down but shifting towards nationalism and being stoked by anti immigration policies by Gove and co. The LP is in a mess in parliament and I can’t see it ending happily for anyone. The far right look set to gain power and with little or no proper opposition can put in place their manifesto…
    So with my head on and ignoring my heart, Corbyn must go but what next…just like Brexit there is no plan! Oh what a mess!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This is eloquently written and hearfelt like everything I’ve read on your blog but here is why I hope you’ll change your mind.

      There’s this idea that ‘if we can just get elected’ we can start to change things and in order to do that we have to make the the views of the party more centrist, more palatable, Corbyn is ‘unelectable’ right? I’ve heard that so many times it must be true.

      You say that the country voted with the far right and that ‘they are not exactly crying out for socialism’ but I think this completely misreads the vote. I think what people voted for was a disruption to the status quo more than anything, I think many people feel so disenfranchised and empoverished that they saw an opportunity to throw a spanner in the works and they took it.

      I have always believed that vast majority of people are fundamentally decent, even people who hold racist views often do so simply because they’re hurting, they’re afraid for themselves and their very existence seems to constantly hang by a thread amidst debts, work pressures, health problems etc. If you meet them and talk to them they are as caring and kind as you or I and they might well be kind to people of other races that they know, but they are against these ‘swarms’ of people that the Right tell them are causing all the problems they experience day to day.

      These people ARE in fact crying out for socialism. The Labour Party as the right of the party would have it be, that Ed Milliband offered at the last election, offers these people nothing, mugs saying ‘Controls On Immigration’ and a promise to carry on with business as usual simply don’t speak to them. Why tack yourself on to the racist message when the right wing parties are SO much better at this. No, what they need is a real alternative, what they need is socialism, they need a counter argument to this which is why people are so desperate to hang on to Corbyn.

      This is really about whether socialism is allowed any place in our political spectrum and if you feel that you are a socialist then I believe you have to hold your nose and back Corbyn, get behind him because you cannot win from a centre ground position. When people are disenfranchised either the Left will speak to them or the Right will. UKIP will presumably win a bunch of seats in the next general election but I strongly believe that these people who are being seduced by the easy answers offered by the Right can only be won back by an equally strong counter argument that speaks to their problems and not to their prejudices.

      Corbyn is not ideal as leader, I’m sure he would agree with this, but it’s what he represents that’s at stake. To not back Corbyn now is to turn your back on the only real political alternative to the racism and hatred taking hold in communities like the one where Jo Cox was so despicably murdered, now sadly nothing more than a footnote in recent events.


  3. Intresting views but I don’t see how moving back to the middle the official position of the last 2 GE campaigns is going to yeild different results. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing again and expecting different results.


  4. “Now is NOT the time for the Shadow Chancellor to be quoting from Mao’s Little Red Book or to talk about printing more money.”

    Correct on the first, but not on the second.

    How else are you planning of offsetting the leakage to pension savings? By confiscating them?

    Labour has to frame a vision. Now I can guarantee everybody a job with a decent living income, a house to live in in their community and a pension to look forward to — all within a society that prioritise education and healthcare for local residents whatever business thinks. Because I understand what power government has within its own currency area to command the resources within it.

    It is time to reframe the debate it terms of what people want. In terms of real things, not money. Because government spending always pays for itself in the UK. Always has, and always will. So you dismiss any suggestion to the contrary as the ramblings of idiots who don’t know what they are taking about. The outpouring of ‘experts’ who are really just experts in fear mongering.

    The government prints money all the time. They are called Gilts and there is no need to issue them and pay rich people interest. Instead we use the ‘Ways and Means’ account like we did before Gordon Brown sold his soul to the finance industry.

    Labour at the moment consists of a set of people that really want to be Greens and set of people that really want to be Tories. There is no unique Labour identity that focuses upon serving the UK. It’s time for Labour to put forward a real identity based upon ensuring every resident has a living wage job if they want one, and controlling immigration so that is possible. That’s what the population wants – a life free from uncertainty.

    Give them that and Labour will sail into government.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s